Question & Answer
Should Founders Offer Pro-Rata Rights to Investors?
Pro-rata rights to investors – a term that often surfaces in funding negotiations but is rarely the focal point of early-stage discussions. Yet, it can be a pivotal clause that significantly impacts the relationship between investors and founders. Should founders offer these rights? And if so, under what conditions?
Let’s break it down.
What Are Pro-Rata Rights?
Pro-rata rights grant investors the option to maintain their ownership percentage in a company by participating in future funding rounds. In practical terms, if an investor owns 10% of a company and the company raises additional capital, pro-rata rights allow that investor to buy new shares to preserve their 10% stake.
For investors, this is about protection. It ensures they are not diluted when the company raises more money. For founders, it’s a balancing act – retaining control while keeping early backers engaged without restricting future fundraising flexibility.
The Pros and Cons
The inclusion of pro-rata rights in an investment deal can have both advantages and disadvantages for both parties.
Benefits for Investors:
- Protection against dilution, maintaining the upside potential of their initial investment.
- Ability to continue investing in successful companies, reducing risk across their portfolio.
- Confidence that they won’t be sidelined in later funding rounds when the company’s valuation is higher.
Benefits for Founders:
- Encourages early investors to stay committed long-term.
- Signals to new investors that previous investors believe in the company’s growth.
- Can be used as a sweetener in negotiations when investors seek additional protections.
Drawbacks for Investors:
- Ties up more capital in future rounds, which might limit diversification.
- Not all investors have the means or interest to participate in later rounds, leading to potential friction.
Drawbacks for Founders:
- Limits flexibility in raising future rounds, as existing investors have priority over new ones.
- Potentially deters new investors who want larger stakes without interference.
- Adds complexity to the fundraising process, particularly in competitive rounds.
A Negotiation Tool
Pro-rata rights are rarely a yes-or-no discussion. They can be structured with conditions. Some investors request strict pro-rata rights from the outset, while others are more flexible, using them as a negotiation lever.
A common approach is to introduce pro-rata rights later in the process as a sweetener. For instance, if an investor is hesitant about valuation or other terms, granting them pro-rata rights can push them over the line without affecting immediate ownership stakes.
Another option is offering selective pro-rata rights. Rather than giving them to all investors, founders can reserve them for those who bring strategic value beyond just capital.
When Should Founders Offer Pro-Rata Rights?
- When seeking to attract long-term investors who can provide follow-on capital.
- As a strategic tool to retain high-value investors without giving away too much equity upfront.
- In deals where an investor is negotiating aggressively for additional rights, making pro-rata a counteroffer.
However, founders should be cautious. If pro-rata rights are granted too broadly, it may limit their ability to bring in fresh investors or negotiate better terms in later rounds.
Pro-rata rights to investors are neither inherently good nor bad – it all depends on how they are structured. For investors, they provide security and upside. For founders, they can be a useful tool but also a constraint. The key is to use them strategically, ensuring they serve the long-term vision of both parties.
As covered in Deal Structuring, understanding investor motivations and structuring deals with foresight is essential. Founders should carefully consider when and how to offer pro-rata rights, ensuring they align with their company’s growth plans.
Deal Structuring
Buy the book today and dive into practical techniques that empower you to get started immediately, navigating transactions efficiently and maximizing your success in minimizing cash requirements.
In this book, you will:
- Be introduced to the fundamentals of deal structuring
- Learn 19 proven deal models for structuring deals
- Discover 39 key elements of deal nuances
- Access 32 actionable clauses for your term sheets
- Explore 9 specific deal structures
- Receive 257 pages of invaluable insights
- Gain the distilled expertise of 20 years